USA Women's Team Trials for Pan-Am Games, 6.10-13.99, Chatham NJ

Five vie for three spots, Final Team named on 6.29.99 by USSRA

D Holleran, L Khan, S Khan, B Belknap named

Report and comment by Ron Beck 6.14.99 (updated 6.29.99)

All photos © 1999, Debra Tessier

[report of the trials]

Strong US Team Named

USSRA Names final team, amidst hope that they have put appeals and controversy to bed.

Bala Cynwyd, June 29 1999. The USSRA today named Demer Holleran, Latasha Khan, Shabana Khan, and Berkeley Belknap as their 1999 Pan American Games team. The team trials and selection were extremely close, with Julia Beaver losing out in a closely fought team-trials round-robin.

With about one month remaining before the 1999 Pan American Games, the USA now has named a women's squash team that on paper is stronger than any fielded before. With Latasha Khan and Shabana Khan currently ranking in the top 30 of the world, and Demer Holleran playing at her best, the team should have a strong opportunity for the top prize.

Appeal made by Julia Beaver

In recent weeks, though, the upcoming competition has been overshadowed by behind-the-scenes sparring over the selection of the team itself. (see report on the trials) An appeal of the selection process had been made by the family of Julia Beaver, who had secured legal counsel to handle their appeal.

The basis of her appeal had been a claim by the Beavers that Latasha Khan and Shabana Khan had not put in their best efforts in the trials. The USSRA executive committee, however, after exhaustive and careful review of both videotapes of the trials and historical information on the play of both Khans, decided that the appeal was without merit.

USSRA Rejected the Appeal

Today (Monday June 29th), Eben Hardie, president of the USSRA and Craig Brand, Executive Director, spoke with SquashTalk to explain the selection process, the appeal, and the final decision.

They emphasized that the appeal had been taken seriously and that members of the women's selection committee (that had been named by Beth Rasin) and the USSRA executive committee had carefully reviewed all of the claims. Hardie made it plain that he had personally reviewed all of the information in substantial detail.

They also told SquashTalk that the USSRA intends to more fully publish and publicize all selection processes and procedures, to make the process in the future fully open to the players and public. Several aspects of the team selection approach may be subject to reform as well. [explanation of the selection process]

All Selected Players deserve their spots

The appeal shouldn't take anything away from the strength and solidness of the selected team. All four players have proved themselves in international competition. Demer Holleran has played very strongly this year, especially at the US Nationals and the Fuzzy Peach in Atlanta this spring. Latasha and Shabana Khan have both shown their strength in international competition, ranking in the top 30 on the WISPA tour. The WISPA rankings are based on a revolving 12-month point system, and give solid evidence of the high level of their play as well as their dedication to regular top-level competition. Latasha Khan, for example, last weekend traveled to Japan and put in a solid showing at the WISPA Japan Open.

Julia Beaver will continue play a strong role

The USSRA committee view both Khan sisters as well as Julia Beaver as a key player in the US women's scene in the future, and so were hopeful that the careful and serious review that was made would be accepted by Julia and her family, though there was not yet an indication as to any further actions by Julia Beaver.

It is clear that the trials were extremely evenly contested, and that Julia Beaver will have a strong role to play in future national team trials.

[USSRA informational page on USA International teams and selection process].

Demer Holleran is the spokesperson on the air: The trials drew TV coverage from NJ Channel 12 Sharon Bradey calmly held court over the closely fought round-robin.
Berkeley Belknap and Latasha Khan (WISPA world ranking # 23) face off in a west-coaster battle. Khan won. Berkeley, Latasha, Shabana, and Demer all have substantial international teams
Another view of Berkeley Belknap and Latasha Khan's face off. It was the only loss for Berkeley in the trials - she ended with a 3-1 record. Latasha and Shabana (WISPA world ranking #27) provided coaching for each other. When they faced off, Shabana beat Latasha on Saturday.
Latasha Khan and Ivy Pochoda faced off on Sunday. Latasha was leading the match but had to retire with an injury, affording Ivy her only win of the trials.
Ivy Pochoda (WISPA world ranking #73) stretching out for full effort against Julia Beaver. Ivy lost this one and two others to crash out of the trials US College #1 Julia Beaver from Princeton had the positive attitude but couldn't match up to the skill and experience of Latasha. Latasha won this won and Julia ended the trial scoring just-too-few games to make it through a tie-breaker.
Demer Holleran (WISPA world ranking #55) was awarded an automatic berth on the US world team. She played an extremely well-fought exhibition with Chatham Club Pro Geoff Mitchell. Demer showed up in possibly the best shape of her life and showed off some unexpected agility.
Julia Beaver and Ivy Pochoda, the youngest hopefuls, however didn't overcome their rivals' experience. Experience beats out youth this time.
[See additional photos of the USA women's trials]       [ visit the rest of the Photo Gallery ]


advertisement

advertisement



Five women vie for three spots on US team: Final team named after appeal and two-week review.

By Ron Beck, Concord MA, © 1999

Coming off a #9 finish in Stuttgart last year in the world championships, the US women have a good opportunity to score well in the PanAm Games this summer; though they will have a fight on their hands to improve on their finish in Germany last year. During last year's competition, neither Shabana nor Latasha Khan, the USA's highest ranking WISPA players, were on the team. So with all of the strongest USA players available this year, a stronger team on paper could be put together.

However, Controversy brewed all spring over the selections and selection process for the USA women's team. This activity came to an interesting climax at the USA trials last weekend at the Chatham Club in Chatham NJ. In extremely closely contested play, Belknap, L Khan and S Khan were selected to join Demer Holleran on the team, with Julia Beaver losing out in a game's won tabulation tie-breaker.

The USSRA has been pushing the USA squash community rapidly toward a more open and transparent approach towards the teams' selection. This is absolutely necessary both for Squash's position vis-a-vis the olympics and the USOC. Additionally, it offers the promise that women's squash will open up more in the coming year, such that players who developed outside of the traditional "hotbeds" -- Philadelphia, Wilmington, Brooklyn NY, and the Ivy League schools, feel that they have an even chance for these international events. The new process is the correct one in order to bring squash out of the protected, and in some people's view rarified, environment that it incubated in for some years. Congratulations to the USSRA for the new approach and to the women for their participation. The difficulty in this case is attributable to the extremely close results of the competition.

The trial process has led to some interesting results in both the womens and mens teams this spring.

The trials taking place this weekend were the outcome of this new approach. They constituted a round robin playoff between the invited players, with the results to be determined first on matches won in the round robin, and then based on number of games won as a tie-breaker -- as it transpired the tie-breaker needed to be invoked. A number of themes developed to the delight of the interested observer:

  • First, youth versus age. The college junior, Julia Beaver, and recent graduate Ivy Pochoda, aiming to take their place on the National team which has been the property for the past several years of a maturing group. Julia Beaver, the youngest pretender, current Princeton Number one and National College Champion, though from the same school, provided the contrast with the experienced Demer Holleran, the team anchor, former Princeton Number one and National College Champion. Demer was awarded an exception from the trial due to her dominance in USA tournament play over the past season.

  • Second, east coast versus west coast, with the west-coasters being obligated to travel east on multiple occasions both for the "qualifying" tournaments and then for the trials themselves. Belknap (San Francisco), and Latasha and Shabana Khan (Seattle) hailing from the west coast, were the reluctant frequent travelers. Berkeley ended the trials with a 3-1 record, and both Khan sisters apparently are due to be selected based on the round-robin tie-breaker system. This gives the west-coasters 3 or the 4 team berths!

  • Third representing opening up of womens squash, the Khans of Seattle, ranked #23 (Latasha) and #27 (Shabana) by WISPA present the strength of west coast, non-ivy-league squash.

    As of Monday June 14th, the matches had been played and the results tallied. Demer Holleran had been excused from the trials and was an automatic team selection. Ivy Pochoda had ruled herself out by her three losses on Friday and Saturday, but the rest of the team is not yet announced by Coach Sharon Bradey and Team Manager Beth Rasin. However Berkeley Belknap was sure to be selected based on her 3-1 record for the weekend. Also, Latasha and Shabana Khan ended up ahead of Julia Beaver, based on a games-won tie-breaker system. Beaver appealed the results of the trial and the USSRA executive committe and women's selection committees spent two weeks in review prior to confirming the results of the trial.

    With the appeal now out of the way, Sharon Bradey will be able to focusing on team preparation.



    June 29 1999


  • Send comments, ideas, contributions and feedback to the webmaster. © Copyright 1999, all rights reserved.

    page updated 6.20.99